Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not to his own facts.
--Daniel Patrick Moynihan
Showing posts with label Iran war. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iran war. Show all posts

June 18, 2026

Trump's Next War

 

By David K. Shipler 

            The Shipler Report has obtained a confidential memo from the Republican National Committee to all senior officials, excluding President Trump, recommending a war plan for future major military assaults. Here is the text: 

PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

EYES ONLY, EXPOTUS 

            To: VP, SecWar, SecState, DNI, DNSA, DDIA, DCIA, JCOS, DNSC, COS--EXPOTUS

            From: RNC Working Group on Imagery (WGI)

            Re: MAD (Mutually Assured Deception) 

Under no circumstances is this memorandum to be shown to the greatest president in the 250-year history of the United States of America. He must be an innocent and unwitting collaborator in this project. 

1.      In consultation with numerous MAGA activists, RNC-contracted pollsters, and voter focus groups, the ongoing WGI project on MAD has developed a war plan for the next military “expedition” that will eliminate risk and maximize (appeared) victory.

2.      In light of the steep costs of the Iran war and the President’s mercurial shifts in rhetorical goals, empty threats, and unrealistic objectives, we suggest a method to be known as Paired Fantasies (PF).

3.      The purpose of PF in the next so-called war is to balance the President’s fantasies about victory, as against Iran, with equally potent fantasies about a war itself.

4.      To wit: Rather than actually sending the US military into combat, the President would simply announce that attacks were being done. Stock video and AI-generated battle and bombing scenes would be distributed to the patriotic news organizations compliant enough to be allowed to cover the Pentagon.

5.      To give this PF scenario verisimilitude, the President should truly think that the war is happening, that he is actually commanding a military venture, thereby fooling himself and the gullible segment of the American public. (We know who they are.)

6.      There would be little chance of the President’s discovering the fictional nature of his “war,” even if the professional military and intelligence leaders let it slip. Since he gets most of his information from Fox, which would be fed the videos, and tends to doze off during briefings, the occasional truthful remark is likely to pass right by him—and if not, he would filter it out to hold his confirmation bias.

7.      In contrast to the war in Iran, this “war” would not result in a single American casualty, of course, and would stir no international outrage or demand for war reparations.

8.      The PF plan coincides with the Iran war at the conclusion, when the President declares a false victory. However, we strongly recommend departing from the Iran case by having the President end his fictitious war with a fictitious peace agreement that awards the U.S. substantial fictitious benefits. We do not want him to pretend, or to do what he usually does, to pretend that he is not pretending. 

Please contact the Republican National Committee’s Working Group on Imagery’s project on Mutually Assured Deception, with any questions or comments. 

This is satire. It’s all made up, a disclosure made necessary by the absurdity of current reality, which prevents lots of people from telling the difference between truth and fiction.

April 12, 2026

Is Israel to Blame for the Iran War?

 

By David K. Shipler 

            Israel’s government under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has given President Trump plenty of bad advice about Iran. But the rising belief that Israel is to blame for Trump’s war of choice deflects responsibility from the White House, where it obviously belongs. Trump failed to weigh Israel’s interests against those of his own country. He reportedly ignored his advisers’ doubts about Israel’s assessments and predictions.

            As the war damages the global economy and security, Israel is being teed up as a scapegoat. A most aggressive effort has come from Tucker Carlson, once a Trump cheerleader, whose recent rant against the war includes a malevolent portrait of a president at the mercy of Israel.

“The Israeli government has a storied history of blackmailing US presidents,” he writes absurdly in his Morning Note. “America’s ‘special ally’ is willing to play very dirty to achieve its goals. Dark-money campaign contributions, extortion, physical threats and even assassination. In their anti-Christian worldview, the ends always justify the means. They have no issue destroying lives.” (Carlson doesn’t mention “Jews,” but those with an antisemitic bent will surely read it that way.)

Americans’ longstanding support for Israel has weakened severely. Unfavorable opinions were driven up by Israel’s widespread bombing and brutal blockade of Gaza Palestinians following the October 7, 2023 atrocities by Hamas, and have risen further since the coordinated Israeli and American war on Iran was launched February 28. A Pew Research Center poll taken in March 23-29 found that 60 percent of American adults hold a negative view of Israel, up from 53 percent last year and 33 per cent in 2022. This could get worse if the conflict is not resolved beneficially to American interests. It’s not truly over, of course, and the eventual outcome will render judgment.

Netanyahu lobbied hard for this war, particularly on February 11, when he gained a rare invitation to a highly-classified meeting in the White House Situation Room. His pitch to Trump came in a period of terrible coincidence, a perfect storm of anxiety and extremism. Gripped by a heightened sense of vulnerability, Israel is led by the most radical, right-wing government in its history. The result is an anti-Arab and anti-Muslim strategy driven by religious absolutism and ethnic bigotry.

After the October 7 attack, a wave of existential fear swept through Israel. Hamas fighters, many on motorcycles, had managed to breach Israel’s high-tech defenses around Gaza, shredding confidence in the intelligence and military establishments. Iran then attacked mainly through its proxy, Hezbollah in Lebanon, forcing Israelis to leave their homes near the border. Others, evacuated from near Gaza in the south, added to an unprecedented population of internal refugees. Israel felt nearly encircled by Iran’s determination to annihilate the Jewish state.

It’s doubtful that Israel’s existence was truly at risk; it still had the Middle East’s most formidable military. But a muffled drumbeat of fear has always run through Israeli society, a legacy of the Holocaust reinforced by the perpetual conflict with the Palestinian Arabs. For most of its history, Israel’s counterpoint to fear has been aggressive defiance, which the Netanyahu government has translated into military onslaughts.

Israel demolished most of Iran’s air defenses and decimated both Hamas and Hezbollah. Last June, the US and Israel coordinated air attacks on Iran’s nuclear facilities. The streets filled with huge numbers of Iranian citizens, hostile to the Islamic Revolution and suffering economically; many were gunned down, but Iran’s government looked weakened. The time for action seemed as ripe as it had ever been.

According to remarkable reporting by Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan in The New York Times, Netanyahu and the head of Mossad, Israel’s version of the CIA, argued that regime change would be triggered by a joint US-Israeli attack. The Israelis even played a video—imagery, not words, seem the major input to Trump’s brain—showing individuals who could take leadership.

March 19, 2026

Trump Meets the Unconquerable World

 

By David K. Shipler 

            One of the most enlightening summations of Donald Trump came from his longtime associate and now chief of staff, Susie Wiles. He has an “alcoholic’s personality,” she said in an interview with Vanity Fair, which means he “operates [with] a view that there’s nothing he can’t do. Nothing, zero, nothing.” She should know. Although Trump claims not to drink alcohol, Wiles grew up with an alcoholic father, the football player and sportscaster Pat Summerall.

            Trump’s fantasy of omnipotence helps explain why he swaggers across parts of the globe and tramples his own country’s democratic norms. But his illusion of boundless power is now running into the reality of Iran. So is Israel’s imagined ability to manipulate the politics of its enemies, a practice it has pursued for decades with absolutely zero success.

Trump has been riding an intoxicating high of adventurism since he found little resistance from earlier targets, bombing Iran’s nuclear facilities last June, blowing up speedboats in the Caribbean, capturing President Nicolas Maduro from Venezuela in January, and now cutting off Cuba’s oil supplies. He said of Cuba, “I can do anything I want with it.” On Iran’s retaliation across the Gulf states, Trump declared, “Nobody expected that. We were shocked.”

 An educable president who took advice from experts would have anticipated the ruthless resilience of Iran’s odious regime. That is not the president Americans elected. Instead, he has rid government of specialists who know Iran. He has made the White House into an echo chamber of zealots and sycophants. He has let his incompetent “Secretary of War,” Pete Hegseth, purge the senior officer corps of many seasoned professionals essential to complex combat.

Furthermore, Trump carries the flaw of every dictator. He thinks policy is personified in a single figure, as in his own administration: hence his misplaced belief that decapitating a government will bring it down, as in the seizure of Maduro and the assassination of Iran’s Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei.

Taking a still picture of a war in progress can be misleading, for the final judgment usually rests on its outcome. So far, the Israel-American onslaught from the air has killed much of the leadership, including potentially moderate figures, and obliterated much of Iran’s military.

The regime remains, however, fighting for its life using asymmetrical warfare against massive Israeli and American air power: mostly drones and rockets aimed at the pressure points of the global oil economy. The US is burning through its arsenal of expensive defensive missiles, which it’s using to down the relative cheap Iranian drones. That limits Ukraine’s ability to get them to hold off Russia, which poses a much graver threat than Iran.

Nor is there any sign yet of the power vacuum that both Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu anticipated could somehow be filled by an unarmed and unorganized opposition. “The hour of your freedom is at hand,” Trump told Iranians on February 28, the day he began the war. “Stay sheltered, don’t leave your home….When we are finished, take over your government, it will be yours to take.”

Perhaps Trump had been persuaded by Netanyahu, the latest in a long line of Israeli leaders who have tried and failed to realign Arab and Muslim politics.

            In the early 1980s, to dilute the Palestine Liberation Organization’s influence in the occupied West Bank, Israel appointed Menachem Milson, a professor of Arabic literature at Hebrew University, as architect of a set of rural “village leagues” composed of moderate, compliant Palestinians. They were seen by the PLO as Israeli collaborators, Jordan threatened to prosecute them for treason, moderate Palestinian mayors denounced their complicity, one member was shot and wounded when his son was killed, and others resigned. Milson impressed Arabs as arrogant and ignorant of their culture, I was told at the time, breaking promises and wielding crude political patronage to no avail.

            Similarly in that period, Israel’s army in occupied Gaza was giving money to the Muslim Brotherhood, a precursor of Hamas. That startling miscalculation was confirmed to me in 1981 by Brig. Gen. Yitzhak Segev, Israel’s military governor for Gaza, who explained that he was instructed to build the Brotherhood as a counterpoint to the PLO and the Communists, whose goal of Palestinian statehood was seen as more threatening than Muslim fundamentalism.

            The Brotherhood was doctrinaire religiously but also deep into social welfare services for the impoverished Gaza population. I suppose the movement seemed benign to Israeli officials whose hubris led them to think they understood the Byzantium of Gaza’s politics.

A year later, Israelis made the same mistake in Lebanon, where they went to war to succeed in expelling the PLO but fail dramatically at realigning Lebanese politics in a pro-Israel direction. Their favored leader, Bashir Gemayel, a Maronite Christian who had led fighters on Israel’s behalf, was assassinated by a pro-Syrian operative shortly after being elected president.

More recently, Netanyahu governments bolstered Hamas to divide Palestinians and cripple their movement for statehood. Years after Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, Israel allowed Qatar to send suitcases full of cash for Hamas through checkpoints into Gaza.

Devoted to Israel’s ultimate destruction, Hamas seemed useful to Netanyahu, because it undermined the Palestinian Authority, which descended from the PLO, favored a two-state solution, and governed parts of the West Bank under the Oslo Accords. The self-destructive result of this bumbling attempt at manipulation came on October 7, 2023, when Hamas fighters caught Israeli intelligence and armed forces off-guard, breached the defenses around Gaza, slaughtered some 1,200 people, took 251 hostages, and triggered Israel’s massive bombing of the territory. In its brutal vengeance during that war, Israel forfeited its moral authority.

Under Trump, the United States is also forfeiting its moral authority. That is an unmeasurable commodity. It cannot be quantified in numbers of missiles, dollars per barrel, or the balance of trade. But its depletion, with allies and adversaries alike, leaves America handicapped in the real world, which even Trump’s megalomania cannot tame.