By David K. Shipler
Come on now, we’re going to go build a mirror factory first and
put out nothing but mirrors for
the next year and take a long look in them.
--Granger, in Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451
A presidential
election campaign is a mirror factory with a deception. We think we are looking
at the candidates, but we are looking at ourselves. Our foibles and dreams are
reflected back at us. The mirrors are unforgiving. They hide no blemishes. All
we have to do is concentrate and watch through clear eyes.
Yes,
politicians are to blame. They give us what they think we want to see. And it
turns out that many of us want to see fantasies: impossible promises, exaggerated
caricatures, and utter illusions. We want to see demons. We yearn for enemies,
both foreign and domestic, to purify complexity into enticing mirages of
simplicity. Too many of us, with the help of certain politicians, conjure up monsters
to blame and hate.
We are
charitable and we are selfish, we are peaceful and violent, accepting and
bigoted. Amid all our vast variety, a large proportion of us look in the
mirrors for tough guys. We don’t want to see softness or empathy in ourselves. We
want to seem caring without being weak. We want hard edges. We want to look in
the mirrors and see in-your-face, tell-it-like-it-is, you-know-where-you-can-put-it,
make-my-day belligerence to confront the whirlwind of self-pity, moral guilt,
and learned helplessness to which we imagine once-great America has succumbed.
That part of us doesn’t want to see
any acquiescence reflected back. If the half or more of us who will vote for
Trump see our reflections honestly in the mirrors, we will see ourselves as
torturers who wish to kill the wives and children of supposed terrorists, as
war criminals who want to plunder (“take the oil”), as pugnacious bullies
spoiling for a war with Iran, as unreliable allies who want turn our backs on
our friends, as advocates for the jailing or assassination of the Democratic
candidate in what we hail as the world’s leading democracy.
When we look straight into our
reflections, we do not see temperate, steady deliberation. We see boiling,
zealous impatience. When a voter can declare that a candidate “says what I
think,” a remark heard frequently from Trump supporters especially, it’s a sign
that the mirrors have been polished.