By David K. Shipler
If you’ve
seen the musical Hamilton or read the book by Ron Chernow, you might have gained some appreciation of dueling, not so
much as a method of ritualized murder but as a conflict-resolution device. Of
course Alexander Hamilton was shot to death by Aaron Burr, which is always a
risk in political confrontations, at least metaphorically. Yet it didn’t have
to end that way. It could have been played more deftly to regain and preserve
honor for both parties.
Perhaps
that’s the answer for President Trump and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, as my friend Steve Weisman impishly suggested over lunch in Washington this week. Trump is
stubborn, and Pelosi’s scrappy, and they’ve wrapped themselves in their egos as
some 800,000 Americans, unpaid during the government shutdown, discover the
pitfalls of working for Uncle Sam.
In
Hamilton’s age, Chernow writes, duels following insults were “de rigueur” among
those “who identified with America’s social elite.” To restore dignity, demonstrate
courage, and avoid being marked as cowardly, rising to the challenge was
unavoidable. However, “duelists did not automatically try to kill their
opponents,” Chernow explains. “The mere threat of gunplay concentrated the
minds of antagonists, forcing them and their seconds into extensive
negotiations that often ended with apologies instead of bullets.”
If
things went too far and you faced off with pistols, you could “throw away your
shot,” that is, aim wildly to avoid inflicting a mortal wound. There’s evidence
that Hamilton did just that in his duel with Burr. But the youthful Hamilton of
years earlier, alight with revolutionary fervor, sings at the outset of the
musical, “I will not throw away my shot!” That’s about both him and his cause. It’s
enough to stir the patriotic heart of any American audience, even in our
dispiriting time.